Home Inicio About Perfil Practice Práctica Insights Perspectivas Contact Contacto
← All Insights Tax Controversy

When the IRS Looks Abroad: What Ultra-High-Net-Worth Individuals Need to Know About International Tax Examinations

7 min read

There is a particular kind of IRS examination that is unlike any other in its scope, its complexity, and its potential consequences. It is the international examination — the audit that reaches beyond the domestic return and into the global financial life of a taxpayer whose wealth, income, and assets exist across multiple jurisdictions. It is the examination that the IRS has been quietly building its capacity to conduct for the better part of two decades. And it is the examination that, more than any other, requires representation from counsel who has been on both sides of it.

I have represented clients in these examinations at every stage — from the initial Information Document Request through Tax Court proceedings. What I have observed is consistent: the clients who fare best are not necessarily those with the cleanest returns. They are the ones whose counsel understood, from the first contact, that an international examination is not a conversation. It is a strategic proceeding, and every decision made in the first thirty days shapes everything that follows.

"In a domestic audit, the IRS reviews your return. In an international examination, the IRS reviews your life — your accounts, your structures, your entities, your transfers, your positions across every country where you have had a financial presence. The scope is as broad as they can make it. Your job, with experienced counsel, is to ensure it is no broader than it needs to be."

The IRS Has Become Significantly More Sophisticated

The era in which a taxpayer could maintain foreign accounts, foreign trusts, or foreign entities with minimal risk of IRS detection has passed. The infrastructure built through FATCA — which requires foreign financial institutions worldwide to report information about U.S. account holders directly to the IRS — has given the agency access to financial data that simply did not exist a decade ago. That data is matched against U.S. tax returns, FBAR filings, and Form 8938 disclosures with automated precision. Discrepancies surface. Examinations follow.

Beyond FATCA, the IRS's Large Business and International division and its dedicated high-net-worth unit have received significant additional funding and staffing in recent years. The agency's stated priority is complex international structures, high-value foreign assets, and taxpayers whose global financial profiles suggest unreported income or improperly claimed deductions. If that description fits you, the statistical probability of examination is higher than it has ever been.

How International Examinations Begin — and Why the First Response Matters

Most international examinations begin with an Information Document Request — a formal, written request for specific records, documents, explanations, and computations. The IDR sets the initial scope of the examination. How it is responded to is among the most consequential decisions a taxpayer will make in the entire process.

Providing too much — submitting documents beyond what was asked, offering explanations that surface issues not yet identified, delivering records in formats that make pattern analysis easier — can open examination threads that would otherwise remain closed. Providing too little invites escalation: follow-up IDRs, summonses, and the kind of adversarial dynamic that makes resolution harder and more expensive.

Experienced counsel does not simply gather documents and send them. Experienced counsel reviews every item for privilege, relevance, and strategic implication before a single page leaves the client's possession. That review — conducted before the response, not after — is where international examinations are shaped.

FBAR Penalties and the Willfulness Question

One of the most significant risks in an international examination is the potential for FBAR penalties to emerge from issues identified in the audit. If the examination surfaces foreign accounts that were not disclosed on the FBAR — whether because the client was unaware of the obligation, uncertain of the threshold, or in some cases, deliberately non-compliant — the penalty exposure can dwarf the underlying income tax at issue.

The central legal question in FBAR penalty cases is willfulness. A willful violation carries penalties of up to the greater of $100,000 or 50% of the account balance per year. A non-willful violation carries a penalty of up to $10,000 per year. The distinction sounds simple. It is not. Courts have interpreted willfulness expansively, and the IRS has used that interpretation aggressively. Managing the willfulness question from the moment an examination begins — through carefully considered responses, properly asserted privileges, and a clear evidentiary record — is among the most important functions experienced counsel performs.

Why This Requires an Attorney, Not an Accountant

In a routine domestic examination, a skilled CPA is often sufficient. In an international examination involving foreign accounts, treaty positions, foreign trust structures, or FBAR issues, the stakes are categorically different — and so is the appropriate representation. The attorney-client privilege protects communications in ways that the accountant-client privilege does not. In a complex examination where the IRS may issue a summons, seek third-party records, or ultimately refer the matter for criminal investigation, that protection is not a formality. It is essential.

If you have received any communication from the IRS related to international issues — a notice, an IDR, a letter from the Large Business and International division, or any contact from the Criminal Investigation division — the right time to engage counsel is before you respond to anything. Not after.

This article is for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal or tax advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship. IRS examination procedures are complex, highly fact-specific, and the outcomes vary significantly based on individual circumstances. Please consult qualified international tax controversy counsel immediately upon receiving any IRS communication.
Received an IRS notice? Do not respond without counsel.
Schedule an immediate confidential consultation with Jamihlia F. Johnson, Esq.
Book a Consultation
← Wealth Without Borders All Insights Bitcoin, Borders, and the New Tax Frontier →